Full explanation
Why the effective interest method applies to lease liabilities
IFRS 16 requires the lease liability to be measured using the effective interest rate method, following the same principles as IFRS 9 for financial liabilities. The underlying logic is that the lease liability is a form of debt — the lessee owes payments in exchange for the right to use the asset. The interest on that debt should reflect the outstanding balance, not a flat annual amount.
Under straight-line interest, the charge would be the same each year. Under the effective interest method, the charge decreases each year as the liability reduces — because interest is calculated on the remaining balance, not the original balance.
The scenario: three-year lease, €40,000 annual payments in arrears, IBR 5%
At commencement, the lessee calculates the opening lease liability as the present value of three payments of €40,000 in arrears at 5%. PV = €40,000 / 1.05 + €40,000 / 1.05² + €40,000 / 1.05³ = €38,095 + €36,281 + €34,554 = €108,930.
Year 1 — interest, payment, closing balance
Opening balance: €108,930. Interest at 5%: €108,930 × 5% = €5,447. Payment at end of year: €40,000. Closing balance: €108,930 + €5,447 − €40,000 = €74,377. Journal entry at payment: Dr Finance cost €5,447 / Dr Lease liability €34,553 / Cr Cash €40,000.
Year 2 — smaller interest on reduced balance
Opening balance: €74,377. Interest at 5%: €74,377 × 5% = €3,719. Payment: €40,000. Closing balance: €74,377 + €3,719 − €40,000 = €38,096.
Year 3 — final balance returns to zero
Opening balance: €38,096. Interest at 5%: €38,096 × 5% = €1,905. Payment: €40,000. Closing balance: €38,096 + €1,905 − €40,000 = €1 rounding difference, effectively zero. Total interest over three years: €5,447 + €3,719 + €1,905 = €11,071. This is the total finance cost recognised in P&L over the lease term.
Journal entries for Year 1
At commencement: Dr Right-of-use asset €108,930 / Cr Lease liability €108,930.
Interest accrual during Year 1: Dr Finance cost €5,447 / Cr Lease liability €5,447.
Annual payment at year end: Dr Lease liability €40,000 / Cr Cash €40,000.
Depreciation of ROU asset (assuming straight-line over 3 years): Dr Depreciation €36,310 / Cr Accumulated depreciation €36,310.
Common mistake: straight-line interest
Dividing the total interest of €11,071 equally across three years gives €3,690 per year. This understates the Year 1 interest by €1,757 (€5,447 minus €3,690) and overstates Years 2 and 3. The lease liability closing balance at the end of Year 1 would also be wrong — €74,690 rather than the correct €74,377. Over the lease term, the same total interest is recognised, but the distribution between years is wrong, affecting reported finance costs, profit, and the liability balance each period.
