Full explanation
Overview
IFRS 16 changes not just what appears on the balance sheet but also the pattern of charges through the income statement. Lease expenses are front-loaded — highest in year one, lower each year after. Here's a full three-year lease: every number from initial recognition to the final payment.
€40k/yr · IBR 7% · IDC €800 · 3 years
Company A enters a three-year lease. Annual payments: forty thousand euros, due at the end of each year. No purchase option. The lessee's incremental borrowing rate is seven percent. Initial direct costs at commencement: eight hundred euros. No variable payments, no residual value guarantees. Commencement date: start of the reporting year.
Recognise ROU asset and lease liability on day one
IFRS 16 paragraph 22: at the commencement date, a lessee recognises a right-of-use asset and a lease liability. Paragraph 26: the lease liability equals the present value of unpaid lease payments, discounted at the rate implicit in the lease or at the lessee's incremental borrowing rate. Paragraph 24: the right-of-use asset is measured at cost, which includes the initial measurement of the lease liability plus any initial direct costs.
Lease liability €104,973 · ROU asset €105,773
Lease liability — present value of three payments of forty thousand euros at seven percent. Year one payment: thirty-seven thousand, three hundred eighty-three. Year two: thirty-four thousand, nine hundred thirty-eight. Year three: thirty-two thousand, six hundred fifty-two. Total lease liability: one hundred four thousand, nine hundred seventy-three euros. Right-of-use asset: one hundred four thousand, nine hundred seventy-three plus eight hundred initial direct costs equals one hundred five thousand, seven hundred seventy-three.
Interest €7,348 + depreciation €35,258 = P&L €42,606
Year one interest: one hundred four thousand, nine hundred seventy-three at seven percent equals seven thousand, three hundred forty-eight. Payment forty thousand. Closing liability: seventy-two thousand, three hundred twenty-one. Depreciation: one hundred five thousand, seven hundred seventy-three divided by three equals thirty-five thousand, two hundred fifty-eight. Closing ROU: seventy thousand, five hundred fifteen. Total year one P&L: forty-two thousand, six hundred six. The old straight-line charge would have been forty thousand, two hundred sixty-seven. Year one is higher — the total over three years is identical.
ROU €105,773 · liability €104,973 · IDC cash €800
Commencement: debit right-of-use asset one hundred five thousand, seven hundred seventy-three — credit lease liability one hundred four thousand, nine hundred seventy-three — credit cash eight hundred. Year one interest: debit finance cost seven thousand, three hundred forty-eight — credit lease liability. Year one payment: debit lease liability forty thousand — credit cash. Year one depreciation: debit depreciation expense thirty-five thousand, two hundred fifty-eight — credit accumulated depreciation on right-of-use asset.
Treating the lease as a flat operating expense of €40k/yr
The common mistake is continuing to recognise a straight-line lease expense — forty thousand euros a year, flat, with no liability on the balance sheet. IFRS 16 eliminated that treatment for most leases. Year one P&L is forty-two thousand, six hundred six under IFRS 16 versus forty thousand, two hundred sixty-seven under the old operating lease method. The difference is front-loading, not extra cost. The balance sheet also carries a one hundred four thousand, nine hundred seventy-three liability on day one that simply did not exist under old GAAP.
