Full explanation
Overview
IAS 16 gives you two ways to record a revaluation — and they produce exactly the same carrying amount and the same revaluation reserve. The difference is only in the journal entry mechanics. Here are both methods, side by side, with the same numbers.
Cost €120k · AD €30k · CA €90k → revalued to €108k
Company A holds plant and equipment. Original cost: one hundred twenty thousand euros. Accumulated depreciation to date: thirty thousand euros. Carrying amount: ninety thousand euros. The asset is revalued at the reporting date. Independent valuation: one hundred eight thousand euros. Revaluation surplus: eighteen thousand euros. Both methods will end with a carrying amount of one hundred eight thousand and a revaluation reserve of eighteen thousand in equity.
Same net result — different journal entry mechanics
IAS 16 paragraph 35 permits two methods. Paragraph 35(b) — the elimination method: accumulated depreciation is eliminated against the gross carrying amount, and the net amount is restated to the revalued amount. Paragraph 35(a) — the gross restatement method: both the gross carrying amount and accumulated depreciation are restated proportionately, preserving the ratio of gross to net. IAS 16 paragraph 39: a revaluation increase is recognised in other comprehensive income and accumulated in equity as a revaluation surplus.
Clear the AD → reduce cost to €108k → €18k to OCI
Method one — elimination. Target: one hundred eight thousand euros. Step one: eliminate the thirty thousand euros of accumulated depreciation in full. Step two: reduce the gross carrying amount by twelve thousand so that cost equals the revalued amount. Journal: debit accumulated depreciation thirty thousand, credit PPE cost twelve thousand, credit revaluation reserve in OCI eighteen thousand. After: gross cost one hundred eight thousand, accumulated depreciation zero, carrying amount one hundred eight thousand.
Factor 1.2 → gross €144k · AD €36k · same CA €108k
Method two — gross restatement. Revaluation factor: one hundred eight thousand divided by ninety thousand equals one point two. Gross cost: one hundred twenty thousand multiplied by one point two equals one hundred forty-four thousand — an increase of twenty-four thousand. Accumulated depreciation: thirty thousand multiplied by one point two equals thirty-six thousand — an increase of six thousand. Net surplus: twenty-four thousand minus six thousand equals eighteen thousand. Journal: debit PPE cost twenty-four thousand, credit accumulated depreciation six thousand, credit revaluation reserve in OCI eighteen thousand.
Different entries — identical balance sheet outcome
Both methods end identically on the balance sheet. Method one: cost one hundred eight thousand, accumulated depreciation zero. Method two: cost one hundred forty-four thousand, accumulated depreciation thirty-six thousand. Both: carrying amount one hundred eight thousand, revaluation reserve eighteen thousand in OCI. The choice between methods does not change the economics — only the gross and accumulated depreciation disclosure amounts differ.
Taking the €18k surplus through P&L — it belongs in OCI
The most common error is recognising the revaluation surplus in profit or loss instead of other comprehensive income. The surplus of eighteen thousand euros is not realised income. IAS 16 paragraph 39 is explicit: a revaluation increase goes to OCI and accumulates in the revaluation reserve within equity. Only on derecognition — or as the reserve is transferred to retained earnings while the asset is used — does the amount leave OCI. Crediting eighteen thousand to P&L inflates reported profit and misstates equity presentation.
