Full explanation
Overview
When a company holds investment property and elects the fair value model under IAS 40, every movement in fair value — gain or loss — goes directly to profit or loss. Not to other comprehensive income. Profit or loss. That's the rule most people confuse with the IAS 16 revaluation model. Here's the full calculation.
Acquisition €850k · Y1 FV €920k · Y2 FV €880k
Company A holds a commercial building classified as investment property. Acquisition cost at start of year one: eight hundred fifty thousand euros. End of year one fair value: nine hundred twenty thousand euros — a gain of seventy thousand. End of year two fair value: eight hundred eighty thousand euros — a fall of forty thousand. The company applies the fair value model under IAS 40. No depreciation is charged.
All FV movements — gain and loss — go to profit or loss
IAS 40 paragraph 33: an entity that chooses the fair value model measures all investment property at fair value after initial recognition. IAS 40 paragraph 35 — the key rule: a gain or loss arising from a change in the fair value of investment property shall be recognised in profit or loss for the period in which it arises. There is no option to use OCI. Both gains and losses go through the income statement, every period, without exception.
Opening €850k → FV €920k → gain €70k to P&L
Year one: carrying amount at start — eight hundred fifty thousand euros. Fair value at year end: nine hundred twenty thousand euros. Change: plus seventy thousand euros. This is a fair value gain. Journal: debit investment property seventy thousand, credit fair value gain in profit or loss seventy thousand. Closing carrying amount: nine hundred twenty thousand euros. No depreciation entry. The entire movement hits the income statement.
Opening €920k → FV €880k → loss €40k to P&L
Year two: opening carrying amount nine hundred twenty thousand. Fair value at year end: eight hundred eighty thousand. Change: minus forty thousand. This is a fair value loss. Journal: debit fair value loss in profit or loss forty thousand, credit investment property forty thousand. Closing carrying amount: eight hundred eighty thousand. Two-year summary: P&L gain year one seventy thousand, P&L loss year two forty thousand. Net income statement impact: positive thirty thousand.
Every movement hits the income statement in the period it arises
Year one full journal: debit investment property seventy thousand, credit fair value gain in profit or loss seventy thousand. Year two full journal: debit fair value loss in profit or loss forty thousand, credit investment property forty thousand. There is no depreciation journal entry under the fair value model. The balance sheet carrying amount equals the current fair value at all times. The income statement receives every movement, up or down, in the period it occurs.
Routing the gain to OCI — that’s IAS 16, not IAS 40
The classic mistake: treating the IAS 40 fair value gain like a revaluation under IAS 16 — recognising the gain in other comprehensive income instead of profit or loss. Under IAS 16, revaluation increases go to OCI first. Under IAS 40 fair value model, there is no OCI option at all. Every gain and every loss hits P&L directly, in the period it arises. Misrouting the year one gain to OCI understates profit by seventy thousand euros and produces a revaluation reserve that should not exist.
