Full explanation
Overview
Recoverable amount is not a single number — it's the higher of two separate calculations. You calculate fair value less costs of disposal, you calculate value in use, and you take whichever is larger. Here is a complete worked example, including the full discounted cash flow for value in use.
CA €320k · Offer €295k · Costs €8k · VIU cash flows at 12%
Company A holds a piece of equipment. Carrying amount: three hundred twenty thousand euros. An impairment indicator is present. An independent buyer has offered two hundred ninety-five thousand euros for the asset. Legal fees and removal costs to complete the sale: eight thousand euros. Pre-tax value-in-use cash flows: ninety thousand in year one, eighty-five thousand in year two, eighty thousand in year three, and seventy-five thousand in year four. Pre-tax discount rate: twelve percent.
Recoverable amount is the higher of FVLCD and VIU — not the lower
IAS 36 paragraph 6 defines recoverable amount as the higher of an asset's fair value less costs of disposal and its value in use. You take the maximum — not the minimum — of the two measures. IAS 36 paragraph 55: the discount rate used in the value-in-use calculation must be a pre-tax rate that reflects current market assessments of the time value of money and the risks specific to the asset. A post-tax rate is not acceptable under IAS 36.
€295k offer − €8k costs → FVLCD = €287,000
Fair value less costs of disposal: take the agreed sale price of two hundred ninety-five thousand euros. Deduct direct costs of disposal — legal fees and removal costs of eight thousand euros. Fair value less costs of disposal: two hundred eighty-seven thousand euros. This is the first candidate for recoverable amount.
DCF sum → VIU = €252,724
Value in use — present value of four cash flows at twelve percent. Year one: ninety thousand divided by one point one two equals eighty thousand, three hundred fifty-seven. Year two: eighty-five thousand divided by one point two five four equals sixty-seven thousand, seven hundred sixty-one. Year three: eighty thousand divided by one point four zero five equals fifty-six thousand, nine hundred forty-two. Year four: seventy-five thousand divided by one point five seven four equals forty-seven thousand, six hundred sixty-four. Total value in use: two hundred fifty-two thousand, seven hundred twenty-four euros.
RA = max(€287k, €252k) = €287k · impairment €33k to P&L
Recoverable amount: higher of two hundred eighty-seven thousand and two hundred fifty-two thousand, seven hundred twenty-four. Recoverable amount: two hundred eighty-seven thousand euros. Impairment loss: carrying amount three hundred twenty thousand minus recoverable amount two hundred eighty-seven thousand equals thirty-three thousand euros. Journal: debit impairment loss in profit or loss thirty-three thousand, credit accumulated impairment on equipment thirty-three thousand. Post-impairment carrying amount: two hundred eighty-seven thousand euros.
Post-tax rate or taking the lower — both overstate impairment
Two common mistakes. First: using a post-tax discount rate for value in use. IAS 36 paragraph 55 requires a pre-tax rate. A post-tax rate understates the discount, inflates value in use, and makes the asset appear more recoverable than it is. Second: taking the lower of fair value less costs of disposal and value in use rather than the higher. The logic of recoverable amount is that if you could recover at least a certain amount by selling, the asset is not impaired below that level. You always take the option that maximises recoverable value.
