Full explanation
Overview
When an asset was impaired in a prior year, IFRS doesn't say that impairment is permanent. If the reason for the write-down reverses, you can recover part or all of that loss — but there is a strict ceiling on how much you can reverse, and there is one asset you can never reverse at all. Here is exactly how to do the calculation.
Machinery €400k · 10-year life · impaired at Year 2 to €240k
Manufacturing Company bought a piece of machinery for four hundred thousand euros at the start of Year one. Useful life: ten years, straight-line, nil residual. At the end of Year two, the market for the product it makes collapses. Recoverable amount falls to two hundred and forty thousand euros. The carrying amount at that date is three hundred and twenty thousand — four hundred thousand minus two years of depreciation at forty thousand a year. The impairment loss is eighty thousand euros.
Only if the estimates have changed since the last impairment was recognised
IAS 36 paragraph 110 requires the entity to assess at every reporting date whether any indication exists that a prior impairment loss may have decreased or no longer exists. If such an indication exists, the entity recalculates recoverable amount. Paragraph 114 states the reversal is recognised only if the estimates used to determine the recoverable amount have changed since the last impairment. A rise in market prices, improved cash flow forecasts, or reduced discount rates can all qualify. Critically — a reversal is not recognised simply because time has passed.
Post-impairment: €30,000/yr dep → CA at end of Year 4 = €180,000
After the impairment, the new carrying amount is two hundred and forty thousand euros. Remaining useful life: eight years. Revised annual depreciation: two hundred and forty thousand divided by eight equals thirty thousand euros per year. By the end of Year four — two full years after the impairment — the carrying amount has fallen to: two hundred and forty thousand minus two years at thirty thousand, equals one hundred and eighty thousand euros.
Reversal cannot exceed what the carrying amount would have been without impairment
At the end of Year four, market conditions have improved. The entity recalculates recoverable amount: two hundred and thirty thousand euros. Can the full difference of fifty thousand be reversed? First, calculate the ceiling. IAS 36 says the carrying amount after reversal cannot exceed what it would have been if no impairment had ever been recognised, net of subsequent depreciation. Had there been no impairment, the carrying amount at Year four would be: four hundred thousand minus four years at forty thousand, equals two hundred and forty thousand euros. The ceiling is two hundred and forty thousand.
Reversal = min(RA, ceiling) − CA = €50,000 to P&L
Reversal calculation: recoverable amount is two hundred and thirty thousand. The ceiling is two hundred and forty thousand. The reversal is limited to the lower of the two — two hundred and thirty thousand. Current carrying amount is one hundred and eighty thousand. Reversal recognised: two hundred and thirty thousand minus one hundred and eighty thousand equals fifty thousand euros. Journal entry: debit accumulated impairment fifty thousand euros. Credit reversal of impairment loss fifty thousand euros — recognised in profit or loss. After the reversal, carrying amount is two hundred and thirty thousand. Remaining useful life is six years. New annual depreciation: two hundred and thirty thousand divided by six equals thirty-eight thousand, three hundred and thirty-three euros.
Ceiling trap · wrong ceiling · goodwill reversal — three errors to avoid
Two common mistakes. First — reversing all the way to the recoverable amount without applying the ceiling. If the recoverable amount were two hundred and seventy thousand — above the ceiling of two hundred and forty — the reversal is still capped at sixty thousand, not ninety thousand. Second — reversing goodwill impairment. IAS 36 paragraph 124 is unambiguous: an impairment loss recognised for goodwill shall not be reversed in a subsequent period. That rule is absolute. The logic is that any recovery in goodwill likely reflects internally generated goodwill, which IFRS prohibits from recognition.
