Full explanation
Overview
When a lease is modified — the term is extended, the payments change, or the scope expands — IFRS 16 doesn't just let you carry on with the original numbers. You have to remeasure the lease liability using an updated discount rate, and then adjust the right-of-use asset to match. Here is the exact calculation.
Office lease €20,000/yr · 5yr · IBR 5% · modified at start of Year 3
Lessee Limited signs a five-year office lease on first of January Year one. Annual payments: twenty thousand euros, paid at the end of each year. Incremental borrowing rate at inception: five percent. The lease liability at commencement is the present value of five payments of twenty thousand at five percent: twenty thousand multiplied by the annuity factor of four point three two nine equals eighty-six thousand, five hundred and ninety euros. The right-of-use asset is also eighty-six thousand, five hundred and ninety euros, assuming no initial direct costs or lease incentives.
No new asset added — this is not a separate new lease
IFRS 16 paragraph 44 says a modification is accounted for as a separate new lease only if it adds the right to use an additional asset not in the original scope, and the payment increase is commensurate with the standalone price of that added scope. Here, no new space is added — only the term is extended. This is therefore not a new lease. Paragraph 45 applies: on the effective date of the modification the lessee remeasures the lease liability by discounting the revised payments at a revised discount rate.
Lease liability at start of Year 3: €54,466
By the end of Year two, the lease liability has amortised as follows. The first year: opening eighty-six thousand, five ninety plus interest of four thousand, three hundred and thirty less payment twenty thousand equals closing seventy thousand, nine hundred and twenty. The second year: opening seventy thousand, nine twenty plus interest three thousand, five hundred and forty-six less payment twenty thousand equals closing fifty-four thousand, four hundred and sixty-six euros. At the first of January Year three — the modification date — the outstanding balance is fifty-four thousand, four hundred and sixty-six euros.
New LL at 6% · 5yr · €20,000/yr = €84,247 · adjustment €29,781
The modification: the lease term is extended by two years, giving five remaining years instead of three. Annual payments stay at twenty thousand euros. The revised incremental borrowing rate at the modification date is six percent — not the original five percent. IFRS 16 requires the revised rate at the date of modification. New lease liability equals the present value of five payments of twenty thousand at six percent: twenty thousand multiplied by four point two one two equals eighty-four thousand, two hundred and forty-seven euros. The adjustment: eighty-four thousand, two-forty-seven minus fifty-four thousand, four-sixty-six equals twenty-nine thousand, seven hundred and eighty-one euros increase.
Dr ROU Asset €29,781 · Cr Lease Liability €29,781 · new dep €16,347/yr
Journal entry at modification date: debit right-of-use asset twenty-nine thousand, seven hundred and eighty-one euros. Credit lease liability twenty-nine thousand, seven hundred and eighty-one euros. The right-of-use asset before modification: original eighty-six thousand, five ninety minus two years of straight-line depreciation at seventeen thousand, three hundred and eighteen per year equals fifty-one thousand, nine hundred and fifty-four euros. After modification: fifty-one thousand, nine-fifty-four plus twenty-nine thousand, seven-eighty-one equals eighty-one thousand, seven hundred and thirty-five euros. New annual depreciation: eighty-one thousand, seven-thirty-five divided by five remaining years equals sixteen thousand, three hundred and forty-seven euros per year.
Using the original 5% instead of the revised 6% at modification date
The classic mistake: using the original five percent rate at the modification date instead of the revised six percent rate. At five percent, the new lease liability would be twenty thousand multiplied by four point three two nine, equalling eighty-six thousand, five hundred and ninety — giving an adjustment of thirty-two thousand, one hundred and twenty-four euros. That overstates the right-of-use asset and understates the interest charge going forward. IFRS 16 is explicit: use the discount rate at the effective date of the modification — which is the lessee's incremental borrowing rate at that date if the implicit rate is not readily determinable. The IBR reflects current market conditions, not the conditions at lease commencement.
