Full explanation
Overview
When you revalue a building upward, the carrying amount rises — and so does the annual depreciation charge. That extra depreciation comes directly from a higher base. But there is an equity movement that runs alongside it, every single year, that most people miss. Here is exactly how depreciation works after a revaluation — and what happens to that revaluation surplus over time.
Building €600k · 20-year life · revalued to €540k at end of Year 5
Property Holdings acquired an office building for six hundred thousand euros at the start of Year one. Useful life: twenty years. No residual value. Straight-line depreciation: thirty thousand euros per year. By the end of Year five, accumulated depreciation is one hundred and fifty thousand, leaving a carrying amount of four hundred and fifty thousand euros. The entity uses the revaluation model under IAS 16. At the end of Year five, an independent valuer puts fair value at five hundred and forty thousand euros.
Surplus €90k to other comprehensive income — not to profit or loss
IAS 16 paragraph 39: an increase in an asset's carrying amount as a result of a revaluation is recognised in other comprehensive income and accumulated in equity as a revaluation surplus. The revaluation gain is five hundred and forty thousand minus four hundred and fifty thousand equals ninety thousand euros. Journal entry: debit property, plant and equipment ninety thousand euros. Credit other comprehensive income — revaluation surplus ninety thousand euros. The asset is now on the balance sheet at five hundred and forty thousand. Remaining useful life: fifteen years.
New annual dep: €540,000 ÷ 15yr = €36,000/yr · excess = €6,000/yr
Depreciation after revaluation is based on the new carrying amount. New annual depreciation: five hundred and forty thousand divided by fifteen remaining years equals thirty-six thousand euros per year. The annual charge has increased from thirty thousand to thirty-six thousand. The difference — six thousand euros per year — is called the excess depreciation. It represents the extra depreciation arising solely from the upward revaluation. Where does the original thirty thousand come from? The original cost of six hundred thousand divided by twenty years. The incremental six thousand is the extra charge driven by the higher valuation base.
Dr Revaluation Surplus €6k · Cr Retained Earnings €6k — not through P&L
IAS 16 paragraph 41 permits — but does not require — an entity to transfer the excess depreciation from the revaluation surplus to retained earnings as the asset is used. The transfer is: debit revaluation surplus six thousand euros. Credit retained earnings six thousand euros. This transfer is made directly in equity — it does not pass through profit or loss. The P&L always shows the full thirty-six thousand depreciation charge. The equity transfer of six thousand is purely a reclassification within equity from the revaluation surplus to retained earnings.
15 × €6,000 = €90,000 — the entire surplus transfers to retained earnings
Over the fifteen remaining years, the revaluation surplus is fully transferred: fifteen years multiplied by six thousand equals ninety thousand euros — exactly equal to the original revaluation gain. By the end of Year twenty, the revaluation surplus is zero. The P&L absorbed the higher depreciation of thirty-six thousand each year. Retained earnings received six thousand of that back through the equity transfer — so the net retained earnings charge attributable to the building, over the fifteen years, was thirty thousand per year: exactly what it would have been under the cost model. The revaluation surplus is always self-liquidating if the transfer option is applied.
Running the transfer through P&L · using original life in the denominator
The common mistake: running the excess depreciation transfer through profit or loss. It never goes through the income statement. The revaluation surplus to retained earnings transfer is an equity-to-equity movement under IAS 16 paragraph 41. A second mistake is calculating the excess depreciation on the wrong base — using the gross cost of six hundred thousand rather than the depreciable amount of five hundred and forty thousand to compute the new charge. Always divide the revalued carrying amount by the remaining useful life, not the original life. If the entity chooses not to make the in-use transfer, the entire revaluation surplus is transferred to retained earnings when the asset is derecognised.
