Full explanation
Overview
Under IFRS 9, the size of your expected credit loss provision depends on which stage a loan is in. Stage one, Stage two, Stage three — each one uses a different ECL horizon and a different basis for calculating interest revenue. The jump from Stage two to Stage three is the one that changes your income statement the most. Here is exactly what changes at each stage.
Credit Bank grants a €1,000,000 corporate loan · EIR 5%
Credit Bank grants a one million euro corporate loan on first of January Year one. Effective interest rate: five percent. The borrower's business is stable and the loan is performing. No significant increase in credit risk. Under IFRS 9 paragraph 5.5.6, the entity measures the loss allowance at twelve-month expected credit losses. This is Stage one. Twelve-month PD: two percent. Loss given default: fifty percent. EAD: one million euros. Twelve-month ECL: one million multiplied by two percent multiplied by fifty percent equals ten thousand euros.
12m ECL = €10,000 · interest on gross carrying amount = €50,000
Stage one journal entries at year-end. Credit loss expense: debit ten thousand euros. Loss allowance: credit ten thousand euros. Interest revenue: five percent applied to the gross carrying amount of one million euros equals fifty thousand euros. In Stage one, interest is always calculated on the gross carrying amount — the full outstanding principal, before deducting the loss allowance. Stage one balance sheet: gross loan one million. Loss allowance: ten thousand. Net carrying amount: nine hundred and ninety thousand euros.
Lifetime ECL €75,000 · additional charge €65,000 · interest still on gross
By Year two, the borrower's sector enters a severe downturn. Payment terms are restructured. No payment has been missed yet — but Credit Bank concludes there has been a significant increase in credit risk since initial recognition. Under IFRS 9 paragraph 5.5.5, the loan moves to Stage two. The measurement switches from twelve-month ECL to lifetime ECL. Lifetime PD: fifteen percent. LGD: fifty percent. EAD: one million. Lifetime ECL: one million multiplied by fifteen percent multiplied by fifty percent equals seventy-five thousand euros. Additional provision required: seventy-five thousand minus ten thousand equals sixty-five thousand euros.
Dr Credit loss expense €65,000 · interest revenue €50,000 (gross, as before)
Stage two journal entry: debit credit loss expense sixty-five thousand. Credit loss allowance sixty-five thousand. Stage two allowance total: seventy-five thousand euros. And here is what most people miss: in Stage two, interest revenue is still calculated on the gross carrying amount. Five percent applied to one million equals fifty thousand euros — identical to Stage one. The larger loss allowance hits P&L through the credit loss charge, not through reduced interest income. Stage two: provision is bigger, but interest revenue does not change.
PV cash flows: €535,580 · ECL = €464,420 · additional €389,420
By Year three, objective evidence of impairment exists. The borrower has missed payments for over ninety days. The loan is now credit-impaired — Stage three. Expected cash flows from collateral: four hundred thousand euros in two years and two hundred thousand euros in three years. Present value at five percent EIR: four hundred thousand divided by one point one zero two five plus two hundred thousand divided by one point one five seven six equals three hundred and sixty-two thousand, eight twelve plus one hundred and seventy-two thousand, seven sixty-eight equals five hundred and thirty-five thousand, five hundred and eighty euros. Stage three ECL: one million minus five hundred and thirty-five thousand, five eighty equals four hundred and sixty-four thousand, four hundred and twenty euros. Additional provision: four hundred and sixty-four thousand, four twenty minus seventy-five thousand equals three hundred and eighty-nine thousand, four hundred and twenty euros.
Interest on net CA €535,580 → €26,779 vs €50,000 on gross — almost halved
Stage three changes interest revenue. Under IFRS 9 paragraph 5.4.1, credit-impaired assets — Stage three — have interest revenue calculated on the net carrying amount, not the gross. Net carrying amount: one million minus four hundred and sixty-four thousand, four twenty equals five hundred and thirty-five thousand, five hundred and eighty euros. Interest revenue: five percent multiplied by five hundred and thirty-five thousand, five eighty equals twenty-six thousand, seven hundred and seventy-nine euros. Compare to Stage one and Stage two, where interest was fifty thousand. The switch from gross to net basis cuts interest income almost in half. That is the most financially significant change at Stage three — not just the larger provision.
